The differences of this ummah are mercy according to a Hadith which inspire intellectual progress. The people participating in this discussion are the most educated about the nuances of holiness than any westerner critical of them. All of these people are part of Ark of Salvation because they love Quran, Sunnah and Ahlulbayt(ra) which are the largest fountains of holiness which is successfully resisting unholy western modernity.
A Shia sister says Sunnah=Ahlulbayt(ra): No they distinguished it. In Shia narrations Imam Jafar As-Sadiq(ra) said: Who opposes Quran or Sunnah commits kufr. Sunnis jump into the city of knowledge of Hadith without the gate, and Shias keep standing at the gate.
Zayn Abiya The Sunnah is Prophet Mohomad , his words were carried on and revived by his Progeny. That means they are the Sunnah.
Ishmael Abraham The words of Ahlulbayt(ra) are similar to Hadith, but they are not exactly Hadith to be accurate. Hadith is still superior to their words.
Zayn Abiya They are the transmitters of hadith. Just admit im right . Why do you have to be so stubborn and egotistical
Ishmael Abraham When they quote a Hadith, they say so, but most Shia narrations are their own quotes not Hadith.
Zayn Abiya Most Shia narrations trace them via reliable sources back to the source ie Prophet.
Ishmael Abraham Look at Al-Kafi, most of it are not Hadith.
Zayn Abiya How do you know ? Were you there ?
Zayn Abiya The kafi has hadith narrated by sunni scholars they just change transmitters
Ishmael Abraham I have read Al-Kafi and most of it’s narrations are not Hadith. Even it has small number of quotes of the People of Cloak.
Rizwan If you say Aal Muhammad* said everything as Hadeeth then why your scholars has not recorded it as Imam Jafar from Imam Baqir from Imam Ali from Imam Husayn from Imam Ali from Rasoolullah (Alayhis salaatu wassalaam) why they stopped it to Imam Abu Jafar or Imam Sadiq there’s only a single conclusion neither the Imams reported everything as Hadeeth nor did the Shia Muhadditheen recorded it as Hadeeth of Rasoolullah*
Ejaz Ahmed There are 92 narration from Holy Prophet ﷺ out of 16000 narration recorded in Al Kafi and according to some Shi’a scholars 2/3 of Al Kafi is weak.
Rizwan All the scholars are inheritors of Anbiya* it doesnt mean they get100% share.
Zayn Abiya Nor do they have equals.
Greg Logan Actually I would not trust anyone in this mess… I have not one meaningful basis for doing so… just lots of word-games – BUT no holiness of God – no power of God – no kindness of God. This is obviously not of God.
Ishmael Abraham The differences of this ummah are mercy according to a Hadith which inspire intellectual progress. The people participating in this discussion are the most educated about the nuances of holiness than any westerner critical of them. All of these people are part of Ark of Salvation because they love Quran, Sunnah and Ahlulbayt(ra) which are the largest fountains of holiness which is successfully resisting unholy western modernity.
Abd Al-Rahman Al-Umawi The Ahlulbayt transmit Sunnahs but beyond ‘Ali ibn Musa they were not exceptionally knowledgable and didn’t carry any Sunnahs
Abd Al-Rahman Al-Umawi Likewise the Sahabah and their students transmitted Sunnahs
A spiritual Ishmaelite 