Between opinionated and apocryphal hermeneutics of Tafsir

When Imam Tabari does Tafsir bil Hadith, rijal critics wake up. When Imam Razi does Tafsir bil Mantiq, he is called opinionated. We need Tafsir bil Hadith with rijal leniency like Imam Tabari, Imam Ibn Kathir and Imam Suyuti to counter Tafsir bil mantiq.